USA Today published an article recently on the dangers of new "barefoot-like" shoe styles. In the report,
podiatrists Kendrick Whitney and Michele Colon actually state that high heeled platforms
are better for your body than ballet
flats or the Vibram Fivefingers. Why? Because a zero-drop shoe – in their
professional opinion – is bad for your legs and feet. In the article, Colon
decries a particular type of shoe because “there’s no structure, essentially no
sole, they’re too flat.”
Run (quickly… and barefoot) from any podiatrist who
claims your foot needs “support.” I cringe whenever I hear a foot doctor say the foot
needs support, or that such-and-such shoe is bad because it doesn’t offer enough
support. And here we have two podiatrists claiming that ultra-hard, immobilizing, high heeled shoes are better for you than low, flexible shoes that allow for natural foot mobility.
It appears to me that
podiatrists like Whitney and Colon do not fully understand or appreciate foot physiology. And I am
astounded – though perhaps not surprised – that it takes a non-podiatrist like
me to set the record straight. They, like so many other members of the medical
community and society at large, are simply brainwashed. They are so
culturally-biased that they cannot see the obvious about human
ambulation or discern "normal" from "natural."
Can you imagine a dentist who sincerely believes that
candy for breakfast, lunch and dinner is the best thing you can do for your
teeth? If the dentist was deceiving his patients merely to increase his own profits,
I would merely despise him. If he were so ignorant of dental hygiene as to
sincerely believe his prescription is best, then…. well, I would be truly afraid to
be his patient. So is our situation, however, with many of today’s podiatrists.
Crazy.
You do not need
shoes. In fact, your feet, knees, hips and spine would be stronger and
healthier if you wore shoes less. That is fact based on human anatomy and
physiology. I invite Whitney, Colon and their shoe-touting colleagues to show
me ANY scientific data that supports a daily necessity for shoes – specifically
the shoes they hype with elevated heels, arch supports, cushioning, etc. In The
Barefoot Book, I provide many, many references to the primary scientific
literature exposing the hazards of shoe use. Whitney and Colon do not tell
readers of USA Today that elevated heels unnaturally shorten the Achilles
tendon, putting strain on the arch and ultimately causing the arch to fall.
They do not mention that narrow toe boxes on shoes cause hallux valgus, bunions
and hammer toe. They neglect to inform that arch supports, elevated heels and
toe springs immobilize the foot and halt the windlass mechanism, which is so crucial to
natural walking. They also forget that athlete’s foot and toenail fungus only
infect us when we encase our feet in warm, moist, closed-toe shoes. And maybe
they don’t know that the leading cause of knee arthritis (probably) is elevated shoe heels
(elderly women get knee arthritis 4x more than elderly men). All of these problems are caused by shoes and rarely seen in barefoot cultures, but suggesting that we go barefoot more seems unimaginable to them.
Here’s a quote from the article: “Best everyday option for
most women: “Something with a 1- or 2-inch heel” that’s well constructed and
fits well, Colon says. “You’re giving the foot a little bit of an arch. It puts
the body in a normal position for walking.””
URGHH. Do you know WHY you’re giving the foot “a little
bit of an arch”? Because you are locking the windlass mechanism in the “engaged”
position. (Please see my video
description of the windlass mechanism). And walking in a 2-inch heel may be
“normal” (meaning it’s accepted by the masses), but it is not natural.
Going barefoot is natural and healthy; wearing shoes is
unnatural and by-and-large unhealthy. In the ideal world you should employ
shoes the same way you employ gloves… only when necessary. In my own life I
have found that I actually need
footwear less often than I need hand protection, even in winter. So, shoes are
unnecessary in most situations and going barefoot is unquestionably healthier, but if you’ve been wearing
shoes all of your life you do need to transition out of them slowly. Shoes create a dependency on shoes. Our
feet have been debilitated by them and they must therefore be rehabilitated (by walking barefoot). Like any
rehab, the process may be uncomfortable at times, but if you complete the requisite
physical therapy you will be stronger and healthier in the end.
Rant over. Thank you.
As a 'Recovering Podiatrist' I can fully agree with & wholeheartedly endorse Daniel's comments above.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, my profession, which initially arose to treat the problems caused by shoes, has largely focused on the shoe rather than the foot. We are brilliant at mitigating some of the adverse effects of shoes, and of course treating the pathologies & deformities which shoes inevitably cause!
I only realised about two years ago that most feet can function perfectly well, in fact actually function optimally, without shoes. The medical & scientific evidence spanning over 100 years proves that shoes not only damage feet, but increase the risk of pathology in ankles, knees, hips & backs.
I am so convinced of barefeet being safer & healthier than any shoes that I gave up wearing them myself twenty months ago, and have never felt better!
Steve Bloor is one of the world's few podiatrists blazing a new foot-health paradigm. WE THANK YOU, STEVE!
ReplyDeleteHere's a link to the original article, the comments are pretty much all questioning the article. No one that has made a comment seems to be taking it seriously. I commented under mwk982.
ReplyDeletehttp://yourlife.usatoday.com/health/story/2011-09-11/The-other-shoe-drops-Most-are-bad-for-feet/50206576/1
Given how heavily health claims for pharmaceutical drugs (and foods) are regulated, it blows my mind that these "experts" can go out and willy nilly assert whatever they wish about shoes.
ReplyDeleteAs podiatrists, are Whitney and Colon not subject to any conflict of interest oversight?
When I was still under the "care" of a podiatrist, his treatments caused me so much pain, I became very depressed because I was convinced I was losing my ability to walk. Thanks to people like you, who tell the world what I instinctively knew to be true, I now go barefoot whenever I can, and only wear minimal shoes when I have to. I am now almost nearly pain free, and it gets a bit better everyday!
ReplyDeleteNot all feet are created equal. As a runner and possessor of flat feet I overpronate when I run. Not wearing shoes would risk far greater injury if I attempted to run continually with this condition.
ReplyDeleteThe author and many commentators on this page point to personal experience as knowledge that trumps that of a, possibly misguided, expert. I suffer noticeable pain just below my kneecap whenever I attempt to run without shoes or without orthoses. The pain impedes my ability to run and only gets worse over time. While I would never prefer high heels, I also don't feel that running barefoot is right for me.
Just as it is important to question in order to seek one's own answers, I think it is also important to remember exceptions and hear out all the facts while one considers multiple sources of advice.
Just found your blog last wk Daniel...appreciate you're shaking up convention.
ReplyDeleteThe podiatrists cited are quoting wonderful 20th century thought around gait. Unfortunately it is the 21st century and legally they are quite literally "cut off at the knees" from looking further up the chain for integrated function (extending the windlast relationship from big toe to top of the head). Here's a fun piece I posted for rehab pros called the 3 Diaphragms, or tongue in cheek, "Your big toe & enlightenment" : )
Keep after them and that tired last century thinking! http://youtu.be/HTkFuPLZ3Uk
I'm glad to have found your blog. My 19yo son has embraced the barefoot lifestyle and has done quite a bit of research on the legalities of being allowed to remain barefoot. So far his only problem is the dining hall at his university. However, my question is about keeping him safe from frostbite this winter -- how concerned should I be? What do you do to keep your feet warm enough when outdoors in the winter?
ReplyDeleteI wish someone would address the problem of having severe flat feet and whether this approach could still be beneficial. Kitakk above states that he can't run barefoot without having worsening pain. He says he needs both shoes and orthoses. Possibly there is something wrong with his technique, but I wish someone would adress this carefully. I have hypermobile flat feet and find it difficult to walk, much less run, any significant distance without support. Also, is there a proper walking technique for those of us with too many MSK problems to begin with running?
ReplyDeleteI trained under Dr. Whitney and his father at Temple in Philadelphia, where I was indoctrinated with their erroneous belief systems, that are not based in science.
ReplyDeleteI received awards for knowledge of orthotic construction and worked for an orthotics lab.
Yet, many of my active patients were not helped by my interventions. I now know why.
I have become so disgusted with the inability of most podiatrists to understand natural foot anatomy, that I am desperately attempting to separate myself from all things podiatric. Including removing mention of being a podiatrist on my business card. Podiatrists hurt people's feet, because most don't understand how feet are supposed to function.
Dr. William Rossi, was a unique podiatrist, who did understand natural foot function, but was ignored by his own profession, in spite of the fact that no other podiatrist has had a greater understanding of foot function and footwear fabrication, based in real life experience and observation.
I am sad to say that I hope active people avoid podiatrists, as their interventions will NOT deliver the health benefits that they need and desire.
I trained under Dr. Whitney and his father at Temple in Philadelphia, where I was indoctrinated with their erroneous belief systems, that are not based in science.
ReplyDeleteI received awards for knowledge of orthotic construction and worked for an orthotics lab.
Yet, many of my active patients were not helped by my interventions. I now know why.
I have become so disgusted with the inability of most podiatrists to understand natural foot anatomy, that I am desperately attempting to separate myself from all things podiatric. Including removing mention of being a podiatrist on my business card. Podiatrists hurt people's feet, because most don't understand how feet are supposed to function.
Dr. William Rossi, was a unique podiatrist, who did understand natural foot function, but was ignored by his own profession, in spite of the fact that no other podiatrist has had a greater understanding of foot function and footwear fabrication, based in real life experience and observation.
I am sad to say that I hope active people avoid podiatrists, as their interventions will NOT deliver the health benefits that they need and desire.
lol dont be so naive, podiatrist hurt peoples feet and promote people's feet to get hurt because they gain profit of unhealthy feet, they are not interested in healthy feet and things that make feet healthy because they need unhelathy feet to gain profit,
Deletei love your web Barefoot Proffesor you are great
ReplyDeletelol men i don't think even the podhiatrists belive that, i think it's propaganda, shoes corporations want to make profit and will lie and say bullshit in order to avoid people using shoes
i think the article is just propaganda, and probably laughing at peoples face, to call them stupid without realising it, like propraganda from ww2 who was a lot of bullshit some of it and sometimes stupid but people believed that
in order to avoid people going barefoot* i said the contrary, i was going to say in order to avoid people avoiding shoes
DeleteHello, I simply needed to let you know, you're dead off-base. Your article doesn't bode well.
ReplyDeletePodiatry south Melbourne
There might some different approaches according to place or knowledge. Your skills depends on how you got an opportunity and where you have trained. Personal or professional training might distinguish between each other.
ReplyDeleteรองเท้าเพื่อสุขภาพราคาถูก
Hi, I am about to embark on a dissertation titled "BAREFOOT OR NOT?". It will focus on early years provisions in the UK for 0-5 year olds and will discuss the implications and benefits of young children wearing shoes all day in childcare provisions. Do you have any relative reviewed literature you could send me that may help me in my studies?
ReplyDeleteGreat Blog you have here. I'd highly recommend checking out Cyber Monday Amazon Deals .
ReplyDeleteHey
ReplyDeleteHope you are doing well.
Thanks for sharing such an awesome article. In my views, the points that you had mentioned above are more than enough and will help me a lot.
Thanks.
WebGlobals
Top Digital Marketing, Website Design and SEO Company in Sydney, Australia.
We boast of reputable Custom Written College Papers writers team comprising of masters and PhD holders. Excellent academic qualifications enable our writers to have substantial experience in how Custom Writing Assignment should be written.
ReplyDeleteThanks again for this great information and Keep up the good work. Very useful post.
ReplyDeleteAustralian Business Telephone Company
Business Telephone Solutions Sydney
telecommunication services sydney
panasonic phone systems sydney
Phone Systems For Small Business Sydney
features of security cameras sydney
small business phone systems sydney
office phone systems for small business sydney
Big thanks for the useful info. Please continue this great work.
ReplyDeletenbn packages sydney
nbn unlimited plans sydney
best unlimited nbn plans sydney
best nbn provider sydney
Term Paper Writing Help provide 100% top-quality Term Papers Online for all their Custom Research Papers Writing levels.
ReplyDeleteCustom College Paper Services online produces different assignments, including Legitimate College Writing Services, to help students deal with the Custom College Essay Services challenges they face every day.
ReplyDeleteTo further enhance cost-effectiveness of Custom Research Paper Services, there is a revision policy for the Custom Research Paper Writing Services where essayist review the task, despite the period that has elapsed since we presented your Legitimate Custom Research Paper assignment.
ReplyDeleteAre you looking to hire a superior Online Essay Editing Writing Services and Essay Editing and Proofreading Services the find the best company for Custom Editing Writing Services.
ReplyDeleteHey
ReplyDeletePlease continue this great work and I look forward to more of your awesome blog posts.
Thanks.
raft slab
Concrete suspended slabs
steel fixing
concrete for driveways
concrete grinding sydney
raft slab
formwork companies in sydney
cove concrete finish
Awesome Blog.its very interesting and informative in reading.
ReplyDeletevideo production in sydney
corporate video production sydney
sydney video production company
corporate video sydney
video production sydney
video business card
Hey
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your efforts in preparing this post. I really like your blog articles.
raft slab
Concrete suspended slabs
steel fixing
concrete for driveways
concrete grinding sydney
formwork companies in sydney
cove concrete finish
bond deck
Awesome Blog.its very interesting and informative in reading.
ReplyDelete24 hour plumber canberra
bathroom renovations canberra
leaky tap
canberra drain cleaning
plumbers in canberra act
hot water replacement canberra
Web property is properly designed in a friendly way Thanks For Sharing Beautiful Memories!
ReplyDeletewww.norton.com/setup
norton.com/setup
office.com/setup
www.office.com/setup
officecomsetup
officesetup
my.norton.com
us.norton.com/setup
login.norton.com
Are you in need of Best Dissertation Writing Services? Then get connected with Affordable Writing Services Online And get your assignment done on time.You will also get Custom Dissertation Writing Services that will leave an impression.
ReplyDelete